We get this question more than any other: should we book the bell tent site or bring our own tent? The two are priced identically. They're on the same wooded property. They come with the same amenities — private fire pit, Adirondack chairs, outdoor dining table, overhead string lights, hot-shower bathhouse access, dog-friendly. The only real difference is the canvas overhead. So why pick one over the other? A few honest patterns emerge from talking to guests after they've stayed in each.
Book the Curated Bell Tent Site If...
- You don't own a tent (and don't want to buy one for one weekend)
- You've never pitched a tent or it's been long enough that you'd rather skip the learning curve
- You're traveling light — flying in, or driving from a long way out
- You'd rather spend Friday afternoon lighting the fire than reading stake instructions
- You want the 'glamping-adjacent' experience without the glamping price point
The curated bell tent site shows up ready. A 16-foot canvas bell tent is already pitched on a level pad, weatherproofed, staked, and waiting. You arrive, drop bedding inside, and start your weekend. For first-time campers especially, this is the most-recommended path — it removes the part of camping that goes wrong most often (the setup) without removing any of the experience that makes camping worth doing.
Book the Bring Your Own Tent Site If...
- You already own a tent you like — even better, one you've used before
- Pitching the tent is part of the ritual you actually enjoy
- You camp a few times a year and have your kit dialed in
- You're traveling with a specific tent setup (oversized family tent, rooftop tent, hammock-tent rig) that wouldn't fit a bell tent footprint anyway
- You like the autonomy of owning every piece of gear at your campsite
The BYO tent site is the same campsite, minus the canvas. You get the same fire pit, the same chairs, the same string lights, and the same bathhouse — and you set up the part of camping you want to set up yourself. For repeat campers this is often the preferred path because it lets the rituals stay intact.
What's Identical Between the Two
- $45/night — same price, both directions
- Private fire pit with cooking grate and Adirondack chairs
- Outdoor dining table
- Overhead string lights
- Hot-shower bathhouse access on-property
- Dog-friendly
- Wooded seclusion — each site set apart from the others
- Five-minute drive to downtown Madison; ten to Clifty Falls State Park
What If You're Still Deciding?
Default to the curated bell tent site if you have any uncertainty. It's the lower-effort path, the lower-risk path, and the path most first-time guests are happiest with by Sunday morning. The BYO site rewards camping experience; the bell tent site rewards anyone who just wants to be at the fire by sunset. If you're somewhere in the middle — own a tent, but haven't used it lately, want the option not to think about it — book the bell tent.
If you'd rather a king bed and a private hot tub than either tent, our luxury glamping tents (the Velvet Buck and Starlit Buck) live on the same property at $175 a night. That's a real choice to weigh, but it's a different one — that's choosing between camping and glamping, not between the two tent setups.
Both tent sites open June 2026. Pick the one that matches the trip you actually want — not the one that sounds the most adventurous on paper. The campfire doesn't know which tent you used to get there.
